A major issue that has contributed to the rise of Hawaii’s physical education problems is its lack of qualified teachers. An astonishing three-quarters of Hawaii’s elementary schools don’t have specialized teachers for P.E. classes. Instead of relying upon hiring qualified P.E. teachers, classroom teachers, who may not even have physical education training, often teach P.E. in elementary schools. Having someone specialized in that field is important, as lifelong habits are formed primarily in elementary school. Having qualified teachers would not only improve the effects of the class for the kids, but it would also help to relieve some of the pressure from the teachers.
Hawaii has long been searching for a correct balance between academic and physical classes. In 2003, it was recommended that the year of physical education should be cut in half in order to incorporate two years of fine arts, foreign language, or career and technical education into the standard graduation requirements. The proposal was presented by the "Graduation Requirements Task Force", a group comprised of high school principals, college admissions staff, and other officials. Despite the acknowledgement of Hawaii’s relatively high youth obesity rate (22 percent, or twice the national average in 2005), talks about reducing P.E. requirements to half of a semester still went through. Such a proposal is a clear example of the lack of care that is given to physical education classes. The importance of physical education has been vastly underestimated, as it is considered to be a replaceable class. It’s been said that although such a change could possibly create a smarter workforce, it would also likely create a sicker workforce. Despite all of the effort that was put into revising the graduation requirements, the controversial plan to cut P.E. requirements was eventually dropped. Although this was a small victory for Hawaii’s physical education programs, it merely prevented from the programs from getting worse. Instead, educators should be looking for ways to improve the quality of P.E. classes that are taught in schools.
This lack of care towards the development of physical education programs has grown into a glaringly, blatant problem. State guidelines require forty-five minutes of P.E. per week for grades K-3, and fifty-five minutes per week for grades 4-5. These requirements fall far under the recommended 150 minutes per week. Not only are these state requirements so low, P.E. isn’t even officially regulated in middle school. The decision makers in Hawaii’s education system just don’t take P.E. seriously enough to take the initiative to improve it.
8 comments:
I agree. Teachers are under-qualified. at Hokulani elementary school, I know a certain kindergarden teacher who has to teach everything in her class, from writing to reading, math and even P.E. because the school doesn't have a full time P.E. teacher I guess. So not only do the teachers have to assess their students according to HCPS (Hawaii Content and Performance Standards), but they have to assess their students on all fields of learning and repeat it every quarter. It's no wonder Hawaii has so few teachers.
i agree that obesity would create a sicker work force.
ALso, it is not a teacher's job to physically educate kids. There get their masters in education, and not PE.
Physical Education should be up to the parents, or an actual PE teachers. This just shows the lack of fuding for schools
John
John, i completely disagree with you, the PE TEACHers are there to TEACH the kids about health and fitness. They are teachers. that is their job. Think about everything you learn in PE, even now. For example the differences between muscular strength and muscular endurance, the importance of eating right and exercising regularly, how to kick a ball, do a pull up, run with the correct form. These are all things that in some cases need to be taught because no one else will (if the parents do not), especially here in the U.S.. I think it is the teacher's job to teach these things, but the parent's job to help the child maintain an active and healthy lifestyle.
hmm Krysten i wonder who that Hokulani kindergarten teacher could be?!? =]
~Liz
I think that it shouldn't be the school's responsibility to provide physical activity for their students. It should be the responsibility of parents to take care of their children's physical health ex.signing them up for sports, dance, etc. Schools should just be responsible for educating about topics like eating healthy, importance of exercising, not doing drugs, etc.
Although I believe it shouldn't be a school's responsibility, I do see the benefits in providing physical activities to help them get rid of excess energy allowing them to focus better.
Although I agree that parents should encourage their children to be active, it's unlikely that the parents would be able to teach their children proper fitness. Specialized teachers will be able to give students the knowledge that they will need to maintain physical health. Most parents will not be able to provide that.
@ John Orr
PE teacher or not, students recieving some sort of help is better than nothing. Sure it's the parent's duty to make sure their child is living healthy at home, but "non PE teachers" can help at school. Such as they can ensure students are eating healthy lunches or they can help kids become active during recess (ie. encourage them to join in a game of football or tag.)
~Patrick Dang
Post a Comment